Feb
16
2015

On Feb. 4, New York Magazine posted a story on the rise in the anti-vaccination movement in light of the measles outbreak. Brennen McKenzie, a veterinarian blogger and past president of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine Association, told New York Magazine that he has seen an uptick in pet owners choosing to skip vaccinations for their pets against distemper and other ailments, such as parvovirus.

Popular Science, in its Feb. 4 post, picked up on this story, noting that there is no way to prove the size of this movement because there is no central U.S. agency that tracks cat and dog vaccinations. Often, the "unscientific fears" humans have about vaccinating their children are transferred to their pets.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) responded to this media attention in its Feb. 6 post. The AVMA expressed concern that the trend to eradicate the domestic dog variant (strain) of rabies in the United States, and make diseases like distemper, parvo and panleukopenia less common, could easily be reversed in the same way that measles is regaining a foothold.

AVMA also named the larger conversation that was occurring—a philosophical difference in how an owner should care for her pet—and urged pet owners to base their decisions about vaccinations on science rather than ideology.

Michael Cavanaugh, DVM, DABVP, and chief executive officer of AAHA, commented on the potential outcome of the anti-vaccine movement. "I was in Chicago last week and the measles outbreak there was a key topic on every news program I saw," Cavanaugh said. "It is disheartening to me that people are not vaccinating their kids or their pets against easily preventable diseases. Those of us old enough to remember what distemper, parvovirus and panleukopenia do to a population of unvaccinated pets hope to never see that again.

"Unfortunately, if enough people choose not to vaccinate their pets, we’ll see such outbreaks again, just as we’re seeing measles outbreaks following the trend of parents not vaccinating their kids," said Cavanaugh. "People need to listen to the experts on these matters and not believe what they might be reading on the internet or hearing from a friend."

For vaccination guidelines, and for information to respond to clients’ concerns, veterinarians can refer to AAHA’s Canine Vaccination Guidelines. For cats, the American Association of Feline Practitioners developed Feline Vaccination Guidelines.

Comments (1) -

LisaT
LisaTUnited States
2/23/2015 2:36:45 PM #

A few comments.  First is that there are two issues here, that of initial vaccination, and that of revaccination.   These two issues are often mixed together when they shouldn't be, they are separate discussions.  There are pet owners that are not giving any vaccinations at all, and a different population that are giving initial vaccinations, ensuring a response was mounted, and then not revaccinating when additional immunity wouldn't be provided.

Secondly, many of the pet owners that are not vaccinating "regularly" (whatever that means), are those that are reading the science.  That's not to say that some aren't and are basing their decisions on emotional arguments, but the vast majority of pet owners have read a bulk of the science, much of it based on Dr. Ron Schultz's work.

Claiming that pet owners are not reading the science is "charging" this debate, when, in many cases, we could just as well state that many vets aren't reading the current science and are basing their decisions on manipulation (vaccinating to get the client through the door), or hanging on to outdated dogma (annual rabies vaccines in 3-year counties or states), or the outdated belief that vaccinations are benign to all receiving them.  There are two sides to this debate.

It's been over a decade since the recommendations were changed to every three year vaccinations (as a stepping stone to even more spaced out), but the number of vets that have ignored the science on this is what makes informed pet owners' heads spin......

The Standard of Veterinary Excellence ®
American Animal Hospital Association | Copyright © 2017 | Privacy Statement | Contact Us