Pain assessment in dogs involves tools that range widely, from functional signs evaluated by owners and physical signs detected by clinicians to physiological signs measured by researchers (Table 2 ). Assessment methods range from empiric and unvalidated (e.g., “How is your dog climbing stairs?”) to validated (e.g., peak vertical forces measured by force plates). Assessment methods vary widely in labor required, complexity, and cost. Pain assessment is most practically divided into the assessment of acute or perioperative pain and chronic pain (Figure 2 ).
TABLE 2
Pain Assessment Methods and Tools for Use in Dogs
Expand All
/
Collapse All
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute and chronic
USER
Veterinarian
EASE OF USE
Moderate, requires training
PURPOSE
Screening, diagnosing, monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not formally validated as an assessment of pain
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute and chronic
USER
Veterinarian and veterinary technician
EASE OF USE
Moderate, requires training
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not formally validated as an assessment of pain
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute
USER
Veterinarian and veterinary technician
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Screening, monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not specific indicators of pain
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute
USER
Veterinarian and veterinary technician
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not formally validated as a stand-alone assessment of pain; forms part of several validated tools
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute and chronic
USER
Owner collects information Veterinarian evaluates
EASE OF USE
Moderate, requires instructions
PURPOSE
Screening, monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not formally validated as an assessment of pain
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute and chronic
USER
Clinical research; dedicated assessment center
EASE OF USE
Challenging and labor intensive
PURPOSE
Screening, diagnosing, monitoring
VALIDITY*
Valid
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute and chronic
USER
Clinical research
EASE OF USE
Challenging to setup and operate
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Valid
CLINICAL METROLOGY INSTRUMENTS (CMIS)
Expand All
/
Collapse All
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner and veterinarian
EASE OF USE
Moderate
PURPOSE
Screening
VALIDITY*
Not validated
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute
USER
Veterinarian and veterinary technician
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Not validated
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Acute
USER
Veterinarian and veterinary technician
EASE OF USE
Moderate
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Moderately validated
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Valid
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Valid
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Limited validation
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Moderately validated
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic, osteoarthritis
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Moderate
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Moderately validated
ACUTE OR CHRONIC PAIN
Chronic
USER
Owner
EASE OF USE
Simple
PURPOSE
Monitoring
VALIDITY*
Valid, not specific to pain
*Based on an overview of published studies assessing validity.a https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1090023318300583?via%3Dihub and https://www.galliprantvet.com/us/en/coast-tools b http://csu-cvmbs.colostate.edu/Documents/anesthesia-pain-management-pain-score-canine.pdf c https://www.newmetrica.com/acute-pain-measurement/ d https://www.galliprantvet.com/us/en/coast-tools e https://www.vet.upenn.edu/research/clinical-trials-vcic/our-services/pennchart/cbpi-tool f https://www.tassuapu.fi/ g https://cvm.ncsu.edu/research/labs/clinical-sciences/comparative-pain-research/clinical-metrology-instruments/ h https://cvm.ncsu.edu/research/labs/clinical-sciences/comparative-pain-research/clinical-metrology-instruments/ i https://www.newmetrica.com/vetmetrica-hrql/